Two portrait photos side by side: on the left, a black-and-white image of a young person with spiked hair and an earring; on the right, a color photo of a smiling child with short light brown hair.
Via Canva

Before the masks, the scream queens, and the midnight premieres, these faces were just names in a yearbook. No fog machine, no fake blood, just a clean photo and a future nobody could see yet. This scroll lines up horror icons at their most ordinary. It’s the calm before the jump scare, the school snapshots behind the roles that kept us up at night.

1. Sissy Spacek – Carrie

Black-and-white portrait of a smiling woman with long, straight, light-colored hair and bangs, looking slightly off to the side, wearing a dark off-the-shoulder top.
via pinterest.com

2. Linda Blair – The Exorcist

A black-and-white close-up photo of a young girl with long, straight hair and bangs, smiling softly and looking directly at the camera.
via pinterest.com

3. Jamie Lee Curtis – Halloween

Black-and-white portrait of a young person with shoulder-length hair, wearing a light-colored collared shirt under a sweater, smiling and looking slightly to the side.
robmartinez / via pinterest.com

4. Tony Todd – Candyman

A black and white portrait of a man with short hair, wearing an open-collared shirt, facing the camera with a slight smile.
horror4us / via facebook.com

5. Anthony Hopkins – The Silence of the Lambs

A black and white photo of a young man wearing a suit, tie, and collared shirt. He has short, wavy hair and is looking directly at the camera with a serious expression. Other people in suits are partially visible behind him.
via pinterest.com

6. Kevin Bacon – Friday the 13th

A black and white portrait of a young person with medium-length straight hair, wearing a patterned button-up shirt, looking directly at the camera with a neutral expression.
kevinbacon / via facebook.com

7. Brad Dourif – Child’s Play

A black-and-white portrait of a young person wearing a suit and tie, with neatly combed hair and a serious expression, looking slightly to the side against a plain background.
scrawling_pen/ via reddit.com

8. Johnny Depp – A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984)

Young person with short, spiky dark hair, wearing a dark jacket over a light shirt, and a cross earring. The image is black and white, with a plain background.
vintageeveryday / via instagram.com

9. Jennifer Tilly – Bride of Chucky

A young woman with long dark hair, wearing a blue button-up shirt, looks slightly to the side with a neutral expression against a plain, softly lit background.
screenshot

10. Robert Englund – A Nightmare on Elm Street

Black-and-white portrait of a young person with light-colored hair, wearing a light suit jacket, white shirt, and dark tie, looking slightly to the side with a neutral expression.
brainmutant / via facebook.com

11. David Arquette – Scream

A teenage boy with short, spiky brown hair smiles at the camera, wearing a green blazer over a white collared shirt. The background is a soft, neutral color, typical of a school portrait.
via pinterest.com

12. Sarah Michelle Gellar – I Know What You Did Last Summer

A young woman with long dark hair smiles at the camera. The image is black and white, and she is wearing a checkered-collar shirt partially visible under a dark jacket. The background is plain.
sarahmgellar / via x.com

13. Virginia Madsen – Candyman

A smiling woman with light brown hair, styled with bangs and waves, wears a blue dress with a white lace collar. She is sitting indoors with a blurred background.
the80sguy / via instagram.com

14. Naomi Watts – The Ring

A young person with light skin, blue eyes, and short blonde hair smiles at the camera. They are wearing a white collared shirt under a gray sweater. The background is plain and neutral.
robmartinez / via pinterest.com

15. Vera Farmiga – The Conjuring

Black and white portrait of a young person with straight, shoulder-length hair, smiling and wearing a dark turtleneck sweater, posed in front of a plain background.
via pinterest.com

16. Ethan Hawke – Sinister

A young person with neatly parted hair smiles at the camera, wearing a dark suit jacket, white shirt, and patterned tie. The background shows large decorative stone balusters. The image is in black and white.
via pinterest.com

17. Florence Pugh – Midsommar

A young girl with light brown hair in pigtails wears a green and white plaid dress with a white collar. She sits against a gray studio backdrop, looking directly at the camera with a neutral expression.
popculturechat / via reddit.com

18. Bill Skarsgård – It

A school portrait of a young boy with light brown hair, blue eyes, and a friendly smile, wearing a white shirt against a dark, plain background.
stephanycalvert / via pinterest.com

Explore more celebrities’ content:

These familiar yearbook smiles later became slashers, final girls, and cult favorites. If you enjoyed this kind of throwback, keep scrolling through these 20 Colorized Photos That Bring Hollywood’s Golden Age Back to Life – The Scroller, or these College Yearbook Photos of Future Heavy Hitters. You can also check out The Wildest Things Celebrities Have Spent Money On.

Meet the Writer

Matt has spent over the last 8 years as both a writer and editor, working in Seattle and Brooklyn, where he is now based. He loves escaping the tirelessly fast pace of the “Mad Apple” that is NYC by taking walks and runs through parks where he’s able to catch up on the latest tea about society from the city’s ever chatty, always hungry, occasionally maniacal, pigeons. They always have a lot to say. When he’s not taking his urban nature strolls, or dutifully combing the deepest rabbit holes of the internet to find the content that’s worth sinking your mind’s teeth into, he’s likely holed up at a dark-lit dive bar with a new book and/or some friends, or just as easily he could be on the hunt for the next addition to his steadily growing plant family.

These days Matt’s caught up in trying to provide folks as many vivid glimpses into the days long since passed as he can, through fun and engaging collections of hand-picked vintage photos.