The 2026 MLS season is finally here, and with the World Cup looming on the horizon in North America, the stakes have never been higher for the league’s biggest names. While some stars spent the last year lifting trophies and breaking records, others found themselves watching from the sidelines or struggling to justify their massive designated player contracts. For these athletes, the new campaign isn’t just about winning games; it’s about reclaiming a narrative that slipped away during a disappointing 2025.
Whether they are recovering from devastating ACL tears or simply trying to find their rhythm in a new tactical system, these players are under the microscope. The arrival of new franchises like San Diego FC and the continued “Messi effect” means there is no room for mediocrity in MLS anymore. Fans are demanding results, and for the following 20 players, 2026 is officially the year of the comeback.
1. Riqui Puig – LA Galaxy
After missing nearly the entire 2025 season with an ACL injury suffered in the 2024 playoffs, the Spaniard is finally back to pull the strings in midfield. The Galaxy felt his absence deeply last year, lacking the creative spark that only a former Barcelona prodigy can provide. All eyes are on his knee and whether he can rediscover the form that made him an MVP frontrunner.
2. Wilfried Zaha – Charlotte FC
Zaha’s first full year in the league was a mix of brilliant flashes and visible frustration within Charlotte’s rigid tactical setup. Despite decent numbers, he never quite looked like the game-changer fans expected when he arrived from Europe. 2026 is his chance to prove he can lead a team to a deep playoff run rather than just being a high-profile name on the roster.
3. Brandon Vazquez – FC Dallas
Following a tough stint and a major injury late in 2025, the USMNT hopeful needs a massive start to 2026 to secure his spot for the World Cup. He remains one of the most clinical finishers in the league when healthy, but his lack of rhythm has become a concern for his club and the country. A move back to a familiar system might be exactly what he needs to find the back of the net again.
4. Pedro de la Vega – Seattle Sounders
The “Pepo” era in Seattle has been plagued by a series of unfortunate injuries that have kept the Argentine youngster off the pitch. Sounders fans have only seen glimpses of his elite dribbling and vision, making him one of the biggest “what-ifs” of the last season. If he can stay fit in 2026, he could easily be the Newcomer of the Year… two years late.
5. Walker Zimmerman – Toronto FC
The landscape of the MLS Eastern Conference shifted on January 2 with the bombshell announcement that Toronto FC had acquired the two-time Defender of the Year. Zimmerman arrives in Canada as a decorated champion, having captained Nashville SC to its first-ever trophy, the 2025 U.S. Open Cup, just months ago. Toronto is betting heavily on his leadership and pedigree to fix a backline that has struggled for consistency, securing his services through 2027 to build a new winning culture.
Trending on The Scroller
6. Paul Arriola – FC Dallas
Arriola is another victim of the ACL curse that hit several stars in 2025, leaving Dallas without their captain for the bulk of the year. Known for his incredible work rate, his absence was a primary reason for the team’s lack of defensive coverage on the wings. His return provides a massive emotional and tactical boost for a side looking to upset the Western Conference giants.
7. Joao Klauss – St. Louis CITY SC
After a historic debut season, Klauss suffered through a “sophomore slump” in 2025, marked by goal droughts and minor muscle injuries. St. Louis’s high-pressing system lives and dies by his ability to hold up the ball and finish half-chances. He enters 2026 needing to prove that his initial success wasn’t just a flash in the pan.
8. Lorenzo Insigne – Toronto FC
The Italian superstar’s tenure in Canada has been a rollercoaster of world-class goals and lengthy injury reports. With Toronto FC undergoing another rebuild, Insigne needs to show he can be the consistent leader his paycheck demands. It’s likely his last chance to leave a positive legacy in the league before his contract winds down.
Sign up for our newsletter
9. Josef Martínez – San José Earthquakes
The legendary striker spent 2025 looking for his old spark, moving through the league but failing to hit the double-digit goal mark. While his clinical instincts are still there, the explosive pace of his MVP years seems to have faded. A fresh start in 2026 with a team that caters to his movement in the box is his only path back to relevance.
10. Carlos Miguel Coronel – New York Red Bulls
Once considered the most reliable keeper in the Eastern Conference, Coronel had a 2025 he’d rather forget, filled with uncharacteristic errors. The Red Bulls’ aggressive style leaves their keeper exposed, and Coronel’s confidence seemed to waver under the pressure last season. He needs a strong primary window to reclaim his status as an elite shot-stopper.
11. Cristian Espinoza – San José Earthquakes
The engine of the Quakes is coming off an unusually quiet 2025, where his assist numbers dipped well below his historical average for the first time. Despite being the creative heartbeat of San Jose, physical fatigue seemed to take a toll on him during the final stretch of the last tournament. In 2026, with a revamped supporting cast, Espinoza needs to prove he is still one of the most dangerous and consistent wingers in the entire league.
12. Dayne St. Clair – Minnesota United
The Canadian shot-stopper had a rollercoaster year in 2025 that even saw him lose his starting spot in key national team matches. While his reflexes remains elite, several high-profile errors with the ball at his feet shook his confidence and the stability of the Loons’ backline. This 2026 season is his definitive chance to reclaim his status as the best goalkeeper in the Western Conference before the World Cup kicks off.
13. Erik Sviatchenko – Houston Dynamo
The veteran Danish center-back was the pillar of Houston’s recent success, but nagging muscle injuries kept him off the pitch for nearly the entire second half of 2025. Without his leadership and tactical reading, the Dynamo defense looked vulnerable and lost the trademark grit that led them to silverware. His return to full fitness in 2026 is vital if the Texas side wants to be considered a serious title contender again.
14. Emil Forsberg – New York Red Bulls
The Swedish playmaker’s arrival in MLS generated massive expectations that weren’t quite met in 2025 due to a series of back issues that limited his minutes. While his technical quality is undeniable, the high-intensity Red Bulls system requires a level of physical durability that Forsberg hasn’t been able to sustain lately. 2026 will determine if the former Leipzig man can truly become the heir to the superstar legacy in New York.
15. Gabriel Pec – LA Galaxy
After an electrifying debut, the young Brazilian suffered from a classic “sophomore slump” in 2025, where rival defenders finally figured out his signature dribbling patterns. His goal production stalled, and he eventually lost his place in the starting XI to summer signings. Pec enters 2026 with the challenge of reinventing his game and rediscovering the unpredictable spark that made him one of the brightest Brazilian prospects in the league.
16. Teemu Pukki – Minnesota United
The legendary Finnish striker struggled to find the back of the net last year, recording his lowest goal tally since arriving in North America. He often looked isolated during the attack, battling younger, faster defenders who anticipated his trademark moves in the box. For 2026, Pukki needs his clinical finishing to return if he wants to help Minnesota break through the first-round playoff barrier.
17. Hany Mukhtar – Nashville SC
The former league MVP seems to have lost the aura of invincibility that once allowed him to score from almost any position on the pitch. 2025 was a year of visible frustration for Mukhtar, who failed to carry Nashville’s offensive burden as he had in previous campaigns. With the team searching for a new tactical identity in 2026, the German maestro must find the individual magic that once made him the most dominant player in MLS.
18. Aaron Long – LAFC
After a year marked by inconsistency and losing his regular spot in the national team call-ups, Long finds himself at a career crossroads in 2026. The LAFC defender showed flashes of his old self, but a lack of rhythm following past surgeries was evident in high-stakes one-on-one duels. Reclaiming his hierarchy this season isn’t just key for his club; it’s his final card to play for a spot on the World Cup roster on home soil.
19. Miles Robinson – FC Cincinnati
Long considered the gold standard for domestic center-backs, Robinson had a complicated 2025, where minor injuries prevented him from finding continuity in Cincinnati’s scheme. Although his recovery pace remains excellent, the lack of minutes hasaffected his coordination with the rest of the backline, leading to uncharacteristic goals conceded. This 2026 season is his platform to silence the critics and prove he is still the most dominant defender in Concacaf.
20. Benjamin Cremaschi – Inter Miami
Messi’s young protégé underwent a steep learning curve in 2025, where excessive minutes and media pressure seemed to drain his energy prematurely. Despite his undeniable talent, his decision-making in the final third was erratic during the closing months of last season. In 2026, with more maturity and a full preseason under his belt, Cremaschi has the mission of transitioning from a “prospect” to an undeniable starter for the most-watched team on the planet.
Want more sports content?
The road to redemption in MLS is never easy, especially with the league’s level of talent rising every single year. As the world turns its attention to North American soccer, these are the stories of resilience we’ll be following most closely. For more deep dives into the world of sports, check out When Rich Athletes Go Broke: 20 Cautionary Tales, or these 20 Dual Sport Athletes Who Excelled at Both Sports. You may also like The Mascots Who Won the Crowd: 20 All-Time Favorites.
