The road to the Super Bowl is often paved with heartbreak, but only a handful of moments truly leave a permanent mark on the record books. In the high-stakes world of the NFL postseason, a single play can transform a struggling franchise into a dynasty or turn a seasoned veteran into a tragic figure. These games aren’t just about the final score; they are about the raw emotion and the “did that really just happen?” factor that keeps millions of fans glued to their screens every January.
From the frozen tundras of the 1960s to modern miracles in high-tech stadiums, playoff history is where legends are forged under immense pressure. Whether it’s a controversial officiating call or an underdog defying impossible odds, these instances have shaped the cultural fabric of American football. As we look back at the most significant dents made in NFL history, we see a recurring theme of resilience, luck, and the sheer unpredictability that makes the postseason the greatest spectacle in sports.
1. Buffalo Bills – “The Comeback” vs. Oilers, 1992 Postseason
This game remains the ultimate gold standard for the phrase “don’t turn the TV off yet.” Trailing by 32 points, Buffalo orchestrated a frantic second-half rally led by backup quarterback Frank Reich that defied every statistical probability in the book. It wasn’t just a win; it became a core part of the Buffalo franchise’s identity, proving to fans that a “never say die” attitude can actually rewrite history. Even for younger fans who weren’t alive to see the 41-38 final score, this game is still whispered about as the greatest Houdini act in NFL history.
2. Tennessee Titans – “Music City Miracle” vs. Bills, 1999 Season
This game is remembered like a perfectly paced short film: kickoff, lateral, sprint, and absolute chaos. With only 16 seconds left on the clock, the Titans pulled off a desperation lateral that looked more like a rugby play than a standard return, resulting in a game-winning touchdown. It’s one of those polarizing moments that still sparks heated bar debates because the “lateral” was so close to being a forward pass that it feels illegal even when the tape says otherwise. To this day, the sheer shock on the Bills’ sideline remains an iconic image of postseason heartbreak.
3. New York Giants – Super Bowl XLII Upset over Patriots, 2007 Season
The Patriots were chasing a historic 19-0 perfect season, but the Giants showed up with nothing but pure, blue-collar stubbornness. The “Helmet Catch” drive is the specific moment etched into everyone’s brain because it looked like the laws of physics were briefly suspended just for Eli Manning and David Tyree. That massive upset didn’t just earn New York a ring; it permanently shifted the cultural conversation about “inevitable” teams and the beauty of the underdog.
4. New England Patriots – 28-3 Comeback in Super Bowl LI, 2016 Season
This performance broke brains in real-time and continues to haunt Atlanta sports fans to this day. After digging a massive 28-3 hole, Tom Brady and the Patriots methodically dismantled the Falcons’ defense, forcing the first-ever overtime in Super Bowl history. It transformed a perceived blowout into a legendary championship clinic, proving that no lead is ever truly safe when a dynasty is involved. It’s the kind of game that changed how coaching staffs manage the clock in the fourth quarter forever.
5. Seattle Seahawks – Rally vs. Packers in 2014 NFC Championship
Seattle’s comeback sequence was essentially a checklist of impossible events: a fake field goal touchdown, a successful onside kick, and a two-point conversion heave that somehow found a receiver. The Seahawks turned a near-certain loss into a Super Bowl trip in a matter of minutes, leaving the Packers in a state of visible trauma. To this day, Green Bay fans talk about that afternoon in Seattle as if it were a localized natural disaster rather than a football game.
Trending on The Scroller
6. Pittsburgh Steelers – “Immaculate Reception” vs. Raiders, 1972 Postseason
One lucky deflection and one incredible catch by Franco Harris changed the trajectory of an entire franchise overnight. The “Immaculate Reception” is treated as the official turning point for the Steelers, marking the moment they transitioned from “lovable losers” to a terrifying 1970s dynasty. It’s arguably the most famous play in NFL lore, fueled by decades of Raiders fans insisting the ball hit the ground before Harris grabbed it.
7. San Francisco 49ers – “The Catch” vs. Cowboys, 1981 NFC Championship
This is the precise moment the 49ers’ era of dominance started to feel like reality rather than a fluke. Joe Montana’s high-arching pass to Dwight Clark in the back of the end zone became the universal shorthand for “clutch” and “dynasty arriving on schedule.” Even four decades later, if you simply say “The Catch” in a room full of football fans, everyone knows exactly which iconic fingertip grab you’re talking about.
8. San Francisco 49ers – “The Catch II” vs. Packers, 1998 Season
This game added a cinematic chapter to the 49ers-Packers rivalry that defined the late 90s. With only seconds remaining, Steve Young found Terrell Owens for a game-winning touchdown that instantly became a part of playoff mythology. It is remembered not just for the emotional finish, but because the drive featured a controversial fumble that helped shape the modern era of instant replay and late-game officiating scrutiny.
Sign up for our newsletter
9. Arizona Cardinals – 2009 Wild-Card Shootout vs. Packers
This game is remembered for being completely out of control in the best possible way, a total points festival that felt more like a video game than a playoff match. The shootout ended with an incredible overtime walk-off defensive touchdown, putting a sudden, jarring end to a game that neither team seemed able to lose. For many, it remains the signature “Larry Fitzgerald in January” memory, showcasing a future Hall of Famer at the absolute peak of his powers.
10. Philadelphia Eagles – “Philly Special”, Super Bowl LII
The Eagles didn’t just win their first Super Bowl; they did it while playing with a level of fearlessness that felt downright disrespectful to the Patriots’ dynasty. The “Philly Special” trick play, where a tight end threw a touchdown to the backup quarterback, became an instant legend because of the sheer guts required to call it on fourth down. It’s the kind of play that transforms a team into a city’s eternal folk hero before the game even officially ends.
11. New Orleans Saints – Surprise Onside Kick in Super Bowl XLIV, 2009 Season
The Saints fundamentally changed the momentum of a Super Bowl with a single, daring decision: stealing a possession right after halftime. The “Ambush” onside kick wasn’t just a smart tactical move; it was a loud statement that the night belonged to New Orleans after years of franchise struggle. It remains one of the boldest coaching calls in history and a masterclass in how to take control of a championship game by force.
12. Baltimore Ravens – Defense-Led title run, 2000 season
While the NFL often prioritizes high-flying offenses, the 2000 Ravens proved that an elite defense can drag an entire team through January. Ray Lewis and his squad treated the postseason like a weekly intimidation session, allowing almost no room for opponents to breathe. The vibe of that run wasn’t “pretty” or “exciting”; it was simply inevitable, establishing a blueprint for defensive dominance that coaches still try to replicate.
13. Tampa Bay Buccaneers – 2002 Playoff run with defense
That Buccaneers team is remembered for a terrifying secondary and a defensive line that could score points just as easily as their offense. Their Super Bowl performance against the Raiders sealed the “defense wins championships” argument for an entire generation of fans. It provided the franchise with its first taste of glory and remains the defining era of the Bucs’ identity, built on hits that fans could feel through their TV screens.
14. Denver Broncos – “The Drive”, 1986 AFC Championship
This is the original “you left John Elway too much time” story that still gives Cleveland fans nightmares. Elway led his team 98 yards down the field in the closing minutes, a march that felt more like a piece of postseason mythology than a standard series of plays. The drive ended the Browns’ Super Bowl dreams and solidified Elway’s reputation as a late-game magician who could conjure wins out of thin air.
15. Cleveland Browns – “The Fumble”, 1987 AFC Championship
Not every historic dent in the playoffs is a happy one, and the Browns were unfortunately on the wrong side of history again just one year later. Just inches away from a game-tying touchdown and a different franchise legacy, Earnest Byner lost the ball in a moment that flipped the script on the spot. It remains the textbook definition of postseason heartbreak, showing how a single mistake can haunt a city for decades.
16. New York Giants – 2007 Postseason road run
This Giants title run didn’t happen because they were the most talented team on paper; it happened because they got hot at the exact right moment. They won three consecutive games in hostile territory against some of the best teams in the league before taking down the undefeated Patriots. It serves as the ultimate modern example of a “team of destiny” catching the right wave and riding it all the way to a trophy.
17. Green Bay Packers – “Ice Bowl”, 1967 NFL Championship
Even before the Super Bowl became the global spectacle it is today, this game established the “winter mythology” of the league. Played in sub-zero temperatures that froze the referee’s whistle to his lips, the conditions were just as much a character as the players. The Packers’ final quarterback sneak to win it is still the most iconic cold-weather image in football history, proving that champions are forged in the frost.
18. Dallas Cowboys – Early-90s dominance run
The Cowboys made the playoffs feel like their personal playground during a stretch of dominance that the league hasn’t seen many times since. Their triple-threat of Aikman, Smith, and Irvin produced an era of flashy, high-scoring football that fans still romanticize today. When people talk about a “90s dynasty,” the star on the side of the Dallas helmet is almost always the first image that comes to mind.
19. Pittsburgh Steelers – Super Bowl XLIII finishing drive vs. Cardinals
Some Super Bowls are remembered for the halftime show, but this one is remembered for Santonio Holmes’ incredible toe-tap touchdown in the final moments. The closing drive was a masterpiece of tension, ending with a catch that barely seemed possible under the pressure of a championship clock. It was a reminder that in the playoffs, one flawless drive can turn a 60-minute game into a forever highlight reel.
20. Kansas City Chiefs – Modern-Era January dominance
The Chiefs have essentially turned the AFC postseason into their own familiar territory during the Patrick Mahomes era. Even when they fall behind or the games get uncomfortably tight, they’ve developed an “aura of inevitability” that other teams spend decades trying to build. This kind of sustained, high-level success is its own massive dent in history, redefining what it means to be a “playoff team” in the modern age.
Explore more sports content:
The history of the NFL playoffs is a collection of moments that prove why we watch: anything can happen when the clock is ticking down. As the new season kicks off, we can only wonder which team will be the next to make a permanent dent in the history books. For more deep dives into the world of sports, check out The NFL’s Most Unforgettable Big Hits Fans Still Talk About, or these 19 Vintage Photos of Football Players (1960s-1990s). You can also enjoy these 25 Yearbook Photos of Famous NFL Players From the 1960s.
