20 Wild West Myths That the History Books Got Wrong

The Wild West has numerous myths regarding its rich history. It’s no wonder. Hollywood especially loves to dramatize various historical events that took place in the Wild West way back in the day. For instance, you might be surprised to know that the whole Hollywood trope about outlaws only wearing black hats while lawmen wore white hats was rooted in fiction. We’ll take a look at more of the common myths that were spread regarding the Wild West.

1. The West Was Lawless and All Chaos

An elderly man wearing a hat and vest stands outside a rustic wooden building. He has a mustache and is dressed in a shirt with a scarf tied around his neck. His hands are in his pockets, and he appears to be looking into the distance.
u/legacyofthewest/via youtube.com

In fact, even though there was a notable amount of crime, numerous frontier towns also managed to have well structured legal systems in place to deal with the ups and downs.

2. Cowboys Only Wore Cowboy Hats

Two men stand by a river under a clear blue sky. The man on the left wears a wide-brimmed black hat and a red shirt, while the man on the right has gray hair and wears a light-colored shirt. They are engaged in conversation.
u/getarchive

The iconic Stetson hat didn’t soar in popularity until the late 19th century. Usually, most cowboys would wear bowler hats or even wide-brimmed hats such as sombreros.

3. Outlaws Wore Black Hats and Lawmen Wore White Hats

A group of people and horses gathers on a muddy racetrack. Several individuals attend to the horses, while others stand nearby, wearing hats. A white fence lines the track, and a few onlookers are visible to the side.
u/getarchive

This Hollywood trope was all creative inspiration. The reality is that both the outlaws and the lawmen were sure to dress practically, and oftentimes did so to remain indistinguishable from one another.

If you think these widely spread myths about the wild west are interesting, make sure to follow us!

4. Gunslingers Engaged in Dramatic Duels

A vintage black and white photo shows several men in cowboy attire standing at a bar counter. They wear hats, vests, and chaps, engaging in conversation. The bar has an ornate wooden design, and the walls are decorated with framed pictures.
u/diamonddogxof/via Reddit

The quick-draw duels that are so often shown in the Western movies were in fact exceedingly rare. Gunfights that did break out were often unplanned and usually transpired in bars or ambushes.

5. Billy the Kid Killed 21 Men

Four men in vintage attire sit around a table playing cards. A bottle and glass are on the table. They wear hats and focus on their hands, engaged in the game. The scene has an old-fashioned, sepia tone.
u/94mike19/via reddit

The notorious outlaw was rumored to have killed one man during each year of his life. However, historians actually think the real number was much closer to four or five.

6. Bank Robberies Were Common

A blue, wooden building labeled "The Bank of Alma" with large front windows and a small fence in the foreground.
u/arizonaghostriders/via youtube.com

Even though the movies try to make it seem like bank robberies would happen all the time out in the wild west, in fact, bank robberies were very rare. The security was very tight, and then the Wild West banks that were targeted were oftentimes very small.

7. The American Frontier Was Mostly Desert

A vintage photo showing four people and a dog in front of a rustic wooden house. Two horses are present, one saddled. The landscape is open with rolling hills and scattered trees in the background.
u/legacyofthewest/via YouTube.com

Most folks would lead you to believe that the American Frontier was largely made up of desert. However, a lot of it actually consisted of fertile plains, forests, and mountains.

8. The Wild West Was Full of Saloon Brawls

Black and white photo of the "Man at the Wheel Saloon". Three men stand in front of the wooden building, with signs for wine and lager. Another man is on the roof, posing with a ship's wheel.
u/brolbo/via reddit.com

When you picture the Wild West you’re not alone if you just picture a ton of saloons that are filled with angry patrons and huge brawls. In fact, most saloons were common community hubs where business, politics, and social events took place.

9. Cowboys Only Rode Horses

A historical black and white photograph shows a bustling scene of a Western frontier town. People in period attire are gathered around horses and wagons, engaging in various activities. Tents and wooden structures are visible in the background.

Largely thanks to all the Western movies that have sprung out of Hollywood, numerous folks are convinced that cowboys would only ride by horseback. However, there were plenty of cowboys that would

10. Women Had No Power in the Wild West

A historical black and white photo of a woman wearing a wide-brimmed hat and a blouse adorned with numerous medals. Her expression is calm, and she stands in front of a backdrop resembling a wooded area.
u/americanexperiencepbs/via youtube

This myth is plain old nonsense. Numerous women were business owners, owned land, and would even serve as law enforcers, with an example being Stagecoach Mary, who was a postal carrier in Montana.

11. Jesse James Was a Robin Hood Figure

Black and white vintage portrait of a young man with wavy hair and sideburns. He wears a suit with a bow tie and looks directly at the camera. The background is plain and gray.
u/trapdoor/via reddit.com

Even though the legend implies that Jesse James would rob the rich to give to the poor, the reality is that he would generally rob those banks and trains, solely for his own personal gain.

12. Sheriff Badges Looked Like Perfect Five-Pointed Stars

Black and white vintage photo of two men wearing hats and suits. Both have mustaches and are seated beside each other, looking directly at the camera. The background shows partial figures of more people.
u/weirdhistory/via youtube.com

In fact, real sheriff badges came in a wide variety of colors. Some of them were homemade, while others were round, and then there were plenty of sheriff badges that didn’t even say “Sheriff” at all.

13. Buffalo Bill Was an Authentic Cowboy

Black and white portrait of a young man with short, wavy hair, wearing a high-collared shirt and a buttoned jacket. His expression is serious, and he gazes directly at the camera. The background is plain.
u/conjuring1900/via reddit.com

Buffalo Billy Cody knew how to work a crowd, and that’s really what he did. He was much more of a showman than he was ever a cowboy.

14. Tombstone, Arizona, Was the Deadliest Town

Black and white photograph of an early 20th-century mining town with scattered wooden buildings and industrial structures, set in a dry, open landscape. Dusty roads intersect the town, and a few hills are visible in the background.
u/marquisofchaos/via reddit.com

While Tombstone had its share of crime, it was by no means the deadliest town. Much of its reputation stemmed from the infamous gunfight at the O.K. Corral.

15. Outlaws Were Easily Recognizable

A cowboy sits on grass beside a saddled horse on a hill, overlooking a vast grassy landscape with scattered grazing horses under a clear blue sky. The cowboy wears a hat and appears to be resting.
u/deleted/via reddit.com

Many of the most notorious criminals that lived during the height of the Wild West also were very keen on carrying out normal lives. They would do their best to blend into their communities until their actual crimes were discovered.

16. Most Cowboys Were Gunslingers

A man dressed in cowboy attire, including a wide-brimmed hat, sits on a horse in an open grassy area. He holds the reins and has a rope coiled at his side. Trees and a landscape are visible in the background. The image is in black and white.
u/deleted/via reddit

In fact, many cowboys were ranch workers who would spend much more time herding cattle than they ever did firing off guns in dangerous situations.

17. The U.S. Government Supported All Homesteaders

A cowboy wearing a wide-brimmed hat and red bandana sits on a brown horse, overlooking a vast herd of cattle scattered across a grassy plain under a clear blue sky.
u/deleted/via reddit

Many settlers would end up facing difficult broken promises, gritty conditions, and land disputes. This would oftentimes result in them then being pushed out by railroads and corporations.

18. The Pony Express Was a Huge Success

A vintage photo shows a group of cowboys on horseback in the foreground, posing with lassos. In the background, a large herd of cattle spreads across an open field, under a clear sky.
u/legitiamatead420/via reddit.com

The Pony Express only lasted for a mere 18 months before the telegraph ultimately ended up rendering it irrelevant. However, Hollywood went and did its thing, and turned it into a legendary service.

19. Gold Rush Miners Struck It Rich Easily

Black and white photo of coal miners sitting and standing in two coal carts inside a mine tunnel. The miners are wearing work clothes and hats, and they appear covered in dust and grime. The tunnel is supported by wooden beams.
u/quickpresentation1/via reddit.com

Most prospectors that were out there keeping themselves busy in the Wild West never ended up finding gold; instead, they were buried in debt and/or working for the mining companies.

20. Cowboys Lived In Isolation On The Open Range

A historic black-and-white photo of a parade on a dirt road in a small town. Several horse-drawn carriages carry passengers in period attire. Spectators line the street, and buildings with signs are visible in the background.
u/weirdhistory/via YouTube.com

This, indeed was not the case. Cowboys would often work together in teams, live in bunkhouses, and generally maintained many close-knit communities. The whole picture of a lone and emotionally vacant cowboy roaming endless plains is mostly just a myth.

About Author