20 Mystical Animals That Prove Cryptozoology Isn’t All Smoke And Mirrors

Last Updated on September 17, 2025 by Matt Staff

Could it be that some of these creatures actually exist, just beyond the reach of modern discovery? Whether passed down through oral tradition or captured in fleeting glimpses by shocked witnesses, the animals on this list blur the line between myth and reality. Let’s dive into 20 animals that prove cryptozoology isn’t all smoke and mirrors.

1. No wonder people believed in the lochness monster, this is a sturgeon

A large sturgeon swims near the water’s surface, its ridged back and elongated body clearly visible through the shallow, slightly murky water.
stillish/via reddit.com

2. A bald eagle? Or a Thunderbird?

A large bald eagle with wings fully spread stands on a grassy yard near a residential street, in front of a house and a parked white car, viewed from inside a window.
usermanheman/via reddit.com

3. People who believed in the Jersey Devil could have just been seeing a hammerhead bat

A person holds a large bat with distinctive features on the left, while the right side shows a black-and-white drawing of a bat-like creature with a long neck and body, resembling the animal in the photo.
stopnswop2/via reddit.com

4. “The landfill I’m working at has a chupacabra running around.”

A thin, hairless animal resembling a coyote stands in grassy, sunlit clearing near dense trees. The animal’s skin appears gray and rough, with large upright ears and a pointed snout.
clericrambo/via reddit.com

5. This Bigfoot shot was filmed in Northern California in 1967

A blurry figure, possibly a large ape-like creature, walks upright in a forest clearing filled with fallen branches and logs. Tall trees with autumn foliage are in the background.
brickantique5284/via reddit.com

6. This is supposedly the only photo ever taken of a tatzelwurm, 1934

Black and white photo of a creature with a fish-like head and exposed teeth partially emerging from the ground, surrounded by grass and dirt. The image appears old and grainy.
pm_meyourears/via reddit.com

7. This photo was taken in Cape Town, South Africa, during WWII

A sepia-toned photo shows a submarine on the ocean surface with several large, shark-like fins visible in the water nearby. A dashed line measures the distance between fins, labeled "64 ft.
oldapple33/via reddit.com

8. Not mothman, but a Stygian owl

A large, dark-feathered owl with striking red eyes perches on a branch amid green leaves, staring directly at the camera.
volley1399/via reddit.com

9. They used to believe in sea serpents, now we know it’s just a dealfish

Two people on a boat at night hold a long, silvery fish with a pointed head and fins, showing off their unusual catch. The background is dark, highlighting the fish’s size.
userdeleted/via reddit.com

10. People in Aden claimed to have found a species of mermaid

Two people stand on either side of a large, upright mermaid figure with a human-like head and fish tail. The photo is labeled "Mermaid – Aden" and appears to be historical in style.
pm_meyourears/via reddit.com

11. Imagine going into your backyard and seeing this, Skunk ape, Sarasota, Florida

A large, hairy creature with glowing eyes is partially hidden behind green palm leaves at night. The surroundings are dark, and only part of the creature's face and figure are visible.
userdeleted/via reddit.com

12. The Spirit Bear? Or a massive polar bear?

A child in winter clothing stands in front of a large, outstretched polar bear hide mounted on a wooden wall, holding a long object, possibly a rifle, with snow on the ground.
hpsauce3/via reddit.com

13. Black bears with mange could explain werewolf sightings

A four-legged animal with sparse, patchy fur on its body and a dark, furry back walks on a dirt path with green grass in the background.
accomplished-ad-530/via reddit.com

14. This photo shows the sheer size of a sturgeon

Five people standing waist-deep in a river, smiling and holding a massive sturgeon fish in front of them, surrounded by forested mountains and trees under a clear sky.
rachel_ba1/via reddit.com

15. Little Doug, a cryptic legend who was on display at the maritime museum

A mummified creature resembling a curled up, mythical animal lies in a sandy display with a sign above reading "Little Doug." An informational plaque is partially visible in the lower right corner.
yettigetter/via reddit.com

16. This photo of the Hook Island Sea Monster has puzzled people for years

A person rows a small boat on calm water near distant hills, while a dark, mysterious shape or shadow resembling a huge underwater creature appears beneath the surface. The image is in black and white.
standard_potential63/via reddit.com

17. The comparison of a “Bigfoot” track vs a human foot

A man in a suit and hat sits on the floor, holding his bare foot next to a large plaster cast of an oversized footprint, highlighting the significant difference in size.
pocket_weasel_uk/via reddit.com

18. Your cryptic legend based on your state

A colorful illustrated map of the United States shows various cryptids in each state, with matching numbered illustrations and a legend naming cryptids such as Mothman, Jersey Devil, and Bigfoot for each state.
lisanaffziger/via reddit.com

19. A shoebill stork stands at 5 feet tall

On the left, a large gray shoebill stork stands on grass. On the right, a black and white line drawing shows a mythical creature with wings, horse-like legs, and a long neck.
userdeleted/via reddit.com

20. No one can figure out what this creature was, spotted in San Antonio, Texas

A brown, canine-like animal with short fur stands on a grassy area near bushes and trees, partially illuminated by sunlight. In the foreground, there is part of a woven outdoor chair.
userdeleted/via reddit.com

Want to see more wacky animal content?

Check out 20 Albino Versions of Animals That Are As Unique As They Are Amazing, or take a look at Nature is Weird: 21 Creatures That Could Be From Another Galaxy. Finally, if you want to see eerie photos of sea creatures, check out 19 Eerie Images of Deep Sea Creatures From Our Oceans

About Author